Smart City: Digital and Ethics Must Go Together
Mobile applications for traffic management, real-time decision-making centers, massive data analysis, network sensors to detect water system leaks, free public wireless Internet access…these are just some of the proposed ways today to make the city “smarter”.
The term “Smart City”, is often used as a slogan, refers to the use of technology and digital data to improve services to the population and the management of cities. There are more and more cities around the world are interested in making the cities smarter. This is not surprising. While digital is ubiquitous and diffuses in all spheres of society, it is normal to seek to integrate it into urban management to take advantage of the benefits it can bring.
Under the influence of the private sector
Currently, the discourse remains oriented by companies that develop technological applications. The choices that the municipalities will make are therefore likely to be guided by the products available, rather than by a rigorous evaluation of their needs. Without denying that the private sector has a role to play, there are important questions about its control over data and public services.
- First, it must be ensured that investments really deliver the benefits expected for citizens. It would then be coherent for the government to be responsible for deciding what technology applications should be used for.
- Secondly, the data of citizens who use public services must not be used for purposes other than those determined by the public, for example when they pass through private servers. For that, one could require that these data be possessed and controlled by the public authorities.
- Thirdly, we must avoid becoming dependent on the private sector, a situation that reduces the authorities’ room for maneuver and is a hindrance to innovation.
For example, companies have a commercial interest in the fact that the technologies are rigid, not very modifiable by the user, and require quick updates. Cities are then linked in the long term to their suppliers. Municipalities then face significant constraints, including the compatibility of products already purchased with other technologies they may want to acquire.
More and more revealing data
The use of mobile apps, geolocation and geographic data processing also raises privacy issues. The citizen, whose physical location is linked to the many traces he leaves in the digital world, currently has no way of controlling what is done with these data, which he often generates without even knowing it. .
Choices in managing this data will have important implications, including the potential for technologies to become a vehicle for citizen surveillance and categorization, for commercialization of the data, or for targeted advertising.
Inescapable bugs and vulnerabilities
The Smart City is both hardware tools and software. For example, sensors built into water systems to detect leaks must be connected, through a wired or wireless network, to computers and data processing software. All of this hardware is at risk of bugs or other failures, compatibility issues, and even cyberattacks.
This raises several other questions. What consequences could these failures or other problems have on the quality of the data collected and the decisions of the municipal authorities? What would be the impacts on people’s daily lives and safety if essential public services such as aqueducts were disrupted by these failures or cyberattacks?
Will the Smart City be more democratic?
The Smart City promises a more transparent and responsive management of citizens. This is intended to make accessible “open” data, which citizens can manipulate them to learn about their city, and have public participation via the Internet, forums or mobile applications. This promise, however, comes up against some pitfalls. For example, for the population who is not connected, does this mean that these people will not have a voice?
A challenge for the future
The Smart City, in one form or another, will become a reality. Nevertheless, it is our responsibility as a society to model it so that it responds to our values. In the coming months, the municipal government and their Smart City partners need to look at the many ethical issues it raises, to help decision-makers make the right choices.